Skip to content
← Back to News
A dimly lit spaceship corridor with a lit storage alcove, a boot on a patterned box and retro stripes on the wall in Concord.
Credit: Image: Firewalk Studios / Sony Interactive Entertainment via IGDB
featureEditorialsFairgame$

Fairgame$ shows why Sony can’t buy its way into live-service success

November 18, 20268 min read

Sony cancelled Fairgame$ after a playtest, while Helldivers 2 became a steady earner. The gap between them comes down to whether players keep coming back.

Sony canceled Fairgame$ on November 10 after a test involving thousands of players. In an email to staff, PlayStation executives Sean Decker and John Doyle praised Haven Studios’ ability to run the game, but said player feedback was mixed and too few people had returned to meet Sony’s expectations. Haven will help develop other PlayStation games while it explores new projects. Sony said the cancellation would bring no layoffs.

At its May 2023 showcase, PlayStation introduced Fairgame$, Concord and Helldivers 2 as part of its multiplayer lineup for PS5 and PC. Fairgame$ never reached the market, Concord went offline two weeks after launch and Helldivers 2 was still earning money for Sony in its third year. The studios had the resources to build their games and prepare years of updates. Sony had the resources to develop all three games and support them with years of updates. But those investments would only pay off if enough players kept coming back.-

Sony wanted multiplayer expertise across PlayStation Studios

FAIRGAME$ screenshot with purple smoke

Sony began working with Jade Raymond’s Montreal studio in 2021, backing its development of an original PlayStation game before acquiring Haven the following year. Alongside the game itself, Sony was interested in the studio’s approach to multiplayer development, particularly how it could make testing and updating games more efficient.

Haven was developing cloud-based tools that allowed teams to test changes without repeatedly downloading new builds. PS5 lead architect Mark Cerny described how this technology could eventually let designers modify a level while others were still playing it. For multiplayer games that depend on regular updates, faster testing could make a considerable difference.

The acquisition was part of Sony’s broader investment in live-service games. The company also acquired Firewalk, which was developing Concord, and brought in Bungie to review projects across PlayStation Studios. In 2023, Sony expected live-service development to account for 60 percent of its investment in PlayStation Studios by the fiscal year ending in March 2026.

However, the strategy was already facing difficulties. By November 2023, Sony had reduced its expectations, with only six of its twelve planned live-service games expected to launch within that period. Internal reviews had also raised concerns about whether some projects would meet players’ expectations.

Fairgame$ needed players to keep coming back

When Haven revealed Fairgame$ in 2023, it introduced a competitive heist game where teams would break into wealthy targets’ properties while rival crews pursued the same loot. Creative director Mathieu Leduc wanted players to approach each robbery differently, creating unpredictable encounters and stories about plans that went wrong.

The concept relied on players returning for more heists. Learning to pull off a robbery with friends could be entertaining, but keeping those missions interesting over time would require enough variety and competition from other crews. Sony has not shared detailed feedback from playtests, making it difficult to determine which aspects worked and where players lost interest. However, how often testers returned would have been an important measure of the game’s long-term appeal.

Competition was another concern. As Decker and Doyle noted, shooters and battle royale games accounted for 35 percent of playtime across PC, PlayStation, and Xbox in Newzoo’s 37 tracked markets in 2025, down from 40 percent in 2024. Even successful releases such as Battlefield 6 and ARC Raiders were competing for attention in an increasingly crowded market.

For Fairgame$ to succeed, Haven needed to convince players that its heists were worth returning to instead of the games they already enjoyed.

Concord went offline before its first season

Firewalk launched Concord in August 2024 with 16 playable characters, 12 maps, and six game modes. The five-on-five shooter encouraged players to switch between characters during matches, earning bonuses that carried over and rewarded different team combinations. Firewalk also promised regular content updates, with new characters and maps available at no additional cost.

Following feedback from the beta, the studio introduced a practice range and allowed players to join matches already in progress. These changes made the game more accessible, but attracting an audience remained difficult. Unlike free-to-play competitors such as Overwatch 2, Concord cost $40, asking groups of friends to pay for a new shooter when they already had established alternatives.

The promise of future updates offered little incentive to players who were hesitant to buy the game in the first place. With a limited audience and little opportunity to build momentum, Sony took Concord offline on September 6, just two weeks after launch. Buyers received refunds, and Firewalk closed the following month, before its planned first season could begin.

Helldivers 2 gave friends a reason to come back together

A lone Helldiver in a hooded cloak stands in a misty alien swamp while a volcano erupts in the distance in Helldivers 2.
A Helldiver crosses a misty swamp on a hostile planet in Helldivers 2 (Image: Arrowhead Game Studios / Sony Interactive Entertainment via IGDB)

Helldivers 2 also launched at $40. Arrowhead had an advantage in the original Helldivers, a 2015 cooperative shooter whose players already knew the risks of calling an airstrike too close to their friends. Moving the sequel from an overhead view to third person made it harder for everyone to see what the rest of the squad was doing. Shared ammunition drops gave players a reason to regroup, while a teammate could recover the samples another player dropped when they died.

Arrowhead built the wider war around that cooperation. In June 2024, players could fight to rescue survivors at a children’s hospital on Vernen Wells or secure the materials for anti-tank mines on another planet. Enough squads chose the hospital to save the children, and Arrowhead made a donation to Save the Children. Friends who usually played on different nights could take part in the same rescue, then see what their missions had helped accomplish.

Helldivers 2 sold more than 12 million copies in its first three months. The early sales established it as a hit, but Sony had invested in multiplayer partly for the income a game could generate between major releases. In its results for the quarter ending in June 2026, Sony named Helldivers 2 alongside MLB The Show as a steady source of revenue.

Keeping a hit running changes the studio that makes it

Even when a multiplayer game attracts an audience, supporting it requires a long-term commitment. Naughty Dog faced that decision in December 2023 when it canceled The Last of Us Online. The studio explained that producing regular content would have demanded so many resources that it could no longer maintain its focus on single-player games.

Sony faced a similar dilemma with Fairgame$, although Haven had yet to establish a reliable audience. Continuing development meant investing in a game whose ability to retain players remained uncertain. Canceling it avoided the additional costs of launching and supporting another live-service title.

Helldivers 2 demonstrated that Sony's multiplayer strategy could succeed, but its popularity offered no guarantee that other projects would find similar audiences. For publishers, the challenge extends beyond attracting players at launch. They also need enough people to keep returning to justify years of continued development.

Tagged In

SonySony Interactive EntertainmentPlaystationHelldivers 2Multiplayer GamesArrowhead Game Studios