
The Game Awards asked fans to judge GTA VI before they could play it
The Game Awards lets critics play late releases early, but fans voting on GTA VI's Best Narrative nomination had only trailers and previews to go on.
Grand Theft Auto VI received eight nominations at The Game Awards on November 17, including Game of the Year, Best Narrative, and Best Performance for Manni L. Perez as Lucia. There was one unusual detail. Rockstar's biggest release in years was still two days away. Yet fans could already vote for GTA VI without having played it.
The nominations appear to follow the rules. Critics and jury members can play games before release, giving them a chance to judge GTA VI firsthand.
Most fans, however, had only seen trailers and previews. Asking them to vote raised a different question about whether the awards were recognizing the game itself or the hype surrounding it.
The deadline allows critics to judge late releases

Games are eligible for The Game Awards 2026 if they become commercially available by November 20 at 9 p.m. PT, putting GTA VI just inside the deadline. The rules also allow publishers to provide early access so critics can evaluate games before submitting their nominations.
This means jury members could have played GTA VI before its November 19 release, even if their reviews were still under embargo. Each voting outlet submits a ballot representing its editorial staff, allowing nominations to reflect firsthand experience rather than trailers or promotional material.
There's a good reason for this system. Games released late in the year deserve the same consideration as earlier titles, and requiring public access before voting would effectively shorten the eligibility period. Advance copies give critics a chance to judge those games without excluding them simply because of their release dates.
Fans were asked to judge a story they had yet to play

The Best Narrative nomination is particularly difficult to justify from a public voting perspective. Trailers can introduce Jason and Lucia, but they reveal little about how their relationship develops throughout GTA VI. Fans voting on November 17 had to rely on Rockstar's reputation rather than firsthand experience of the story.
The Game Awards already has a Most Anticipated Game category for upcoming releases. Best Narrative serves a different purpose, asking voters to compare the writing of games released that year. Including GTA VI before launch meant fans could support Rockstar based on expectations while judging games like Control Resonant and Resident Evil Requiem on their actual stories.
Public voting accounts for just 10 percent of the final result, with the jury determining the remaining 90 percent. Rockstar's popularity therefore cannot guarantee a win, although fan support could influence a close contest.
Of course, voters rarely play every nominated game. Time, money, and platform availability all limit what people can experience. But GTA VI presented a different problem. Even fans who wanted to play it before voting couldn't do so because the game hadn't been released.
Allowing fans to change their votes misses the point

The Game Awards allows fans to change their votes until December 9 at 6 p.m. PT, giving GTA VI players nearly three weeks to reconsider their choices. Organizers have even encouraged voters to revisit their ballots after spending more time with the nominees.
That sounds reasonable, but it puts the responsibility on fans to correct a problem the organizers could have avoided. Someone voting for GTA VI on November 17 was judging Rockstar's reputation and promotional material. They would then have to return after launch to decide whether the actual game deserved their support. There's no guarantee they would bother.
The solution is straightforward. With eligibility closing on November 20, public voting could begin after every nominated game has been released. That would still leave almost three weeks before the December 9 deadline. Critics could continue using advance copies to select nominees, while fans would at least have the opportunity to play them before voting.
Rockstar hardly needs an early ballot to generate excitement. Its eight nominations already demonstrate how much attention GTA VI commands. If The Game Awards wants its public vote to recognize the year's best games, it should give players a chance to experience them first.

Grand Theft Auto VI heads to the state of Leonida, home to the neon-soaked streets of Vice City and beyond in the biggest, most immersive evolution of the Grand Theft Auto series yet.