RPG is the genre most likely to start an argument because it covers too much ground. Some players want party drama. Some want tactical combat. Some want a world they can disappear into for weeks. For this list, I kept it fairly strict. These are games where character-building, role-playing, decision-making, and long-form immersion are the point, not just something bolted onto another genre.
The ranking runs from great to untouchable. A few of these are older now. A few are very recent. All of them still feel alive when you actually sit down and play them, and that matters more than nostalgia or reputation on its own.
10. Mass Effect Legendary Edition
This still earns its place because few RPGs understand party chemistry as well as Mass Effect. The shooting has aged in different ways across the trilogy, and the first game is rougher than memory likes to admit, but the larger thing still lands: building Shepard, shaping relationships, carrying decisions forward, and dragging one of gaming’s best squads through a story that genuinely feels like a saga. The remastered package helps because it turns three great arguments into one very easy recommendation.
9. Dragon Quest XI S: Echoes of an Elusive Age
There is something refreshing about an RPG that is this comfortable with being warm, clear, and traditional. Dragon Quest XI S does not spend its time trying to prove how clever it is. It trusts good towns, a lovable party, clean turn-based battles, and an adventure that keeps opening without losing its sense of direction.
The definitive edition only makes that easier to appreciate. It is big, but it does not feel bloated, and that alone separates it from a lot of games that aim for the same runtime.
8. Divinity: Original Sin 2
This is still one of the best RPGs for players who want systems that can be bent, broken, and laughed at on the way down. The joy of Divinity: Original Sin 2 is that it keeps giving you room to be crafty, rude, or gloriously reckless. Fights can turn into chain reactions.
Story scenes can go sideways in a heartbeat. Co-op changes the whole mood of the thing. It sits here because the writing does not hit as hard as the games above it, but as a sandbox for tactical role-playing, it is still viciously good.
7. Disco Elysium: The Final Cut
If the word “role-playing” is supposed to mean becoming somebody specific, damaged, and difficult, Disco Elysium deserves to live near the top of any list like this. There is almost no combat to hide behind. Instead, the build is your mind, and your mind is a loud, unreliable disaster.
That is the whole trick. Skills interrupt, flatter, mock, and mislead you until the detective you are playing starts to feel less like a blank lead and more like a real mess of a person. It is lower than the games above it only because it is so pointed and so particular.
6. Metaphor: ReFantazio
Atlus finally left the classroom behind and built a fantasy RPG that still carries the same social pressure, time management, and turn-based snap that made its modern work so easy to get lost in. The difference is that Metaphor feels broader and a little hungrier.
The world has more political weight to it, the calendar structure has real momentum, and the combat moves with a speed that stops the long runtime from ever turning into housekeeping. It is not as effortlessly stylish as Persona 5 Royal, but in some ways it is the bolder game.
5. Persona 5 Royal
This is still one of the easiest hundred-hour recommendations in the genre. The hook is not just the style, though the style remains ridiculous in the best way. It is the rhythm. School life, social links, palace runs, stat-building, tiny daily choices, then suddenly you are fifty hours in and every spare afternoon feels oddly valuable.
Royal earns this spot because it does not just have good turn-based combat or a good cast. It knows how to make routine feel addictive, and very few RPGs understand that skill as well as this one.
4. Final Fantasy VII Rebirth
This is the blockbuster on the list, but it earns its place through generosity rather than sheer scale. Rebirth is huge, yes, but it is also playful in a way many prestige RPGs are not. The party is the real draw.
Cloud, Tifa, Aerith, Barret, and the rest carry the whole thing with a warmth that stops the larger spectacle from feeling cold. Combat helps too. Square Enix has found a sweet spot where action, magic, party-switching, and big cinematic nonsense can all live in the same fight without stepping on each other.
3. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
This remains one of the safest picks in the genre because it still does the hardest part better than most: it makes side content feel worth caring about. The main story is strong, but the smaller stories are what keep The Witcher 3 high on lists like this.
A contract turns into a tragedy. A village problem becomes something bitter and human. A detour stops feeling like a detour. The combat has never been the sharpest thing about it, but the writing, the mood, and the world still make it one of the fullest RPGs to just live in for a while.
2. Clair Obscur: Expedition 33
A year ago this would have looked like a reach. Now it feels obvious. Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 forced its way into the top tier because it feels focused in a genre that often confuses sprawl with value. The turn-based combat has timing and tension. The world has a look of its own.
The story carries grief without drowning in it. Most importantly, the whole game feels shaped. It knows when to move, when to hit hard, and when to leave something unsaid. That kind of discipline is rare in RPGs, and players clearly responded to it.
1. Baldur’s Gate 3
This is still the one. Not because it is the newest anymore, and not just because it is huge, but because it keeps reacting in ways other RPGs still struggle to match. Your build matters. Your party matters. Your dialogue choices matter. Your terrible ideas matter.
The game has a rare elasticity to it, where even odd or reckless decisions often turn into proper stories instead of dead ends. Add in a great cast, genuinely funny writing, tactical combat with real room for mischief, and a world that keeps opening in satisfying ways, and it still feels like the modern standard for the genre.
Discussion
0
We want to hear from you. Share your perspective in the comments below, and please keep the conversation respectful.
Log in to join the discussion - vote, reply, and share your take.
